un and global governance lecture 9 [6cc6cb17]
Tags: UN and Global Governance
- interactions of host societies and external actors causes issues within peacebuilding
- current inadequacies in peacebuilding, resources must be shifted to new ones
-
what is a civil society?
- does a civil society exist? - peacekeeprs usually enter with an idea of what the society looks like
- what are the expectations? what do the host societies expect these people to do?
-
AGE report talks about lack of funding leading to unmet expectations
- host societies do not trust the UN
-
how long should the UN be in a region?
- AGE report states that the UN should commit to long term peace building projects
-
Talentino -> international actors should make a meaningful impact and get out
- is this framing incorrect? Afghanistan and Iraq
-
who needs to be brought into the loop?
-
AGE -> focused on more collaboration between the UN pillars
-
should also work with the international financial instiutions
- World Bank, IMF, etc
-
-
-
How should we approach the range of social actors?
- war torn societies are not lacking in structure, they simply have a different structure that may not be apparent to the western eye
-
is the binary of the bottom up approach and top down approach valid? does this binary hold?
-
local NGO's may not exist
- where does the local become the national? when it does it become the international?
- when does NGO's replace local capacity?
-
somalialand -> benefitted from sustained grassroot initatives
- vs somalia -> largely top down
-
civil vs political binary?
- depends on the situation -> civil socities are not untainted, oftentimes political organizations
- hybrid notions of interaction
- concerns about INGO's and UN replacing state capacity?
-
-
tension between simple narratives and complex issues
- simple narratives may tild the overall framing and moving it twards
1. religious actors in peacekeeping
1. religious actors in peacekeeping
- andrea barkloy notre dame -
- older work in the 90's and 2000's and comparative religious institutions in negotiations
- latin america - rural catholic priests